Moonworkers
Blog

Status determination statement: an IR35 guide for clients

What a status determination statement must contain under IR35, who issues it and when, the 45-day disagreement process and how deemed employers run PAYE.

Status determination statement: an IR35 guide for clients

Work out your take-home pay

Income tax, National Insurance and net pay for any UK salary, 2026-27.

This article was written with the help of AI.

A status determination statement (SDS) is valid only if it meets three tests: it states the worker's status, it gives reasons, and it shows that the client took reasonable care [1]. If any one of the three is missing, the client becomes liable for the income tax, National Insurance and Apprenticeship Levy that should have been deducted [2]. A worker or deemed employer who disagrees must receive an answer within 45 calendar days [3].

The SDS sits at the centre of the off-payroll working rules, often called IR35. Since the reforms extended client responsibility to medium and large private and voluntary sector organisations, the client, not the contractor's own company, decides whether the rules apply to each engagement [4]. That decision travels down the supply chain in the form of the SDS, and it tells the fee-paying party whether to run the payment through PAYE.

For clients, recruitment agencies, accountants and payroll bureaux, the document is therefore more than paperwork. It decides who is the deemed employer, whether tax and Class 1 National Insurance are deducted, and who carries the bill when HMRC disagrees. This guide explains what the statement must contain, who issues it and when, how disagreements work, and how a "caught" engagement flows through payroll, with worked figures recomputed by the Moonworkers payroll engine.

Key takeaways

  • An SDS must state whether the worker would be an employee if engaged directly, give the reasons for that conclusion, and be reached with reasonable care, or it is not valid [1] [2].
  • The client must give the SDS to the worker and to the party it contracts with, on or before the first payment, or the client remains responsible for the tax [5].
  • Clients must answer a disagreement within 45 calendar days of receiving it, or they take on the deemed employer liability until they respond [3] [6].
  • Small private sector clients do not issue an SDS: the worker's intermediary decides status itself [7].
  • When the SDS says the rules apply, the deemed employer deducts income tax and employee National Insurance, pays employer National Insurance and reports through RTI [8].

What a status determination statement is

A status determination statement is the client's written conclusion on whether a worker, supplied through their own intermediary (usually a personal service company), would be an employee or office holder if engaged directly. HMRC describes the off-payroll working rules as existing to make sure that workers who would have been employees, had they been hired directly, pay broadly the same tax and National Insurance as employees [9]. The SDS is the mechanism that records that decision and passes it to everyone who pays the worker.

Where the duty comes from

The obligation sits in Chapter 10 of Part 2 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, which HMRC's Employment Status Manual covers from ESM10000 onwards [10]. Section 61NA sets out what the statement must say and who must receive it [11]. HMRC's internal guidance then explains how the client should communicate the decision to the worker and to any third party it contracts with [5].

The determination itself is a hypothetical test. It assumes a direct contract between the client and the worker, with nobody else in the chain, and applies the normal employment status principles [1]. Those principles are the same indicators used for any worker: control, substitution, mutuality of obligation and financial risk, set out in HMRC's status guidance [12].

Who must issue one

Only public sector clients and medium or large private and voluntary sector clients issue an SDS [4]. A client that is small under the Companies Act tests does not determine status at all; the worker's intermediary decides whether the rules apply and accounts for any tax itself [7]. Clients wholly based overseas are also outside the rules [4].

A private company counts as medium or large if it exceeds two or more of three size conditions. The April 2025 Employer Bulletin confirms that these conditions changed for accounting periods beginning on or after 6 April 2025 [13].

Size conditionThreshold for a small company (accounting periods from 6 April 2025)Previous threshold
Annual turnoverNot more than £15 millionPreviously £10.2 million
Balance sheet totalNot more than £7.5 millionPreviously £5.1 million
Average number of employeesNot more than 50Unchanged

Because size is measured by reference to earlier financial years, HMRC states that the new thresholds have no practical effect on off-payroll working until 6 April 2027 at the earliest [13]. Groups need care: when a parent undertaking is medium or large, its subsidiaries must also apply the rules [4].

What a valid SDS must contain

HMRC sets three criteria and treats them as cumulative. If any one fails, the SDS is invalid and the liability stays with the client [1] [2].

RequirementWhat it means in practiceConsequence if missing
A status conclusionA clear statement that the worker would, or would not, be an employee or office holder if engaged directlySDS invalid, client liable
ReasonsEnough explanation for the worker and the deemed employer to understand the conclusion and challenge itSDS invalid, client liable
Reasonable careEvidence that the decision was reached thoroughly, on the actual terms and working practicesSDS invalid, client liable

The conclusion and the reasons

The conclusion must be explicit. HMRC's Guidance for Compliance states that advertising a role as "inside IR35" or "outside IR35" is not, on its own, an SDS [2]. The reasons must relate to the employment status indicators and be detailed enough for the worker and deemed employer to make representations under the disagreement process [1].

A short statement that "the worker is under the client's control" without explaining how the work is directed, what happens if the worker sends a substitute, or whether the worker can refuse tasks gives the reader nothing to challenge. HMRC's guidance on making determinations encourages clients to involve someone who understands the work, rather than leaving the decision to procurement or finance alone [14] [15].

Reasonable care

HMRC defines reasonable care as acting "in a way that would be expected of a prudent and reasonable person in the client's position" [15]. The standard scales with the organisation: a multinational with an in-house tax function is expected to do more than a smaller client [15]. The Guidance for Compliance adds that the client should keep a record of how each determination was reached [14].

Indicates reasonable careIndicates a lack of reasonable care
Applying the status indicators accurately and keeping a recordTreating every intermediary worker as caught without looking at the facts
Completing CEST accurately and applying its resultEntering inaccurate answers into CEST
Seeking qualified professional adviceIgnoring relevant evidence about the engagement
Reviewing determinations after a material changeFailing to reconsider after the terms or working practices change
Checking the process of any third party used to make the decisionSubcontracting the determination without checks

The table summarises HMRC's own examples [15]. Blanket determinations are the most common failure. A group determination is acceptable only where the workers are engaged on the same terms and actually work under them [15] [14].

Using CEST as the SDS

HMRC's employment status tool, CEST, can produce the SDS directly. HMRC states that it will stand by a CEST result if the information entered is accurate and the tool is used in line with its guidance, and the saved answers and result can serve as a valid SDS [16]. The Employment Status Manual confirms that issuing a CEST output shows that the client agrees with it [1].

CEST has practical limits. Progress cannot be saved part of the way through, and the user needs details of the contract, the worker's responsibilities, who decides how and where the work is done, and how the worker is paid before starting [16]. Third-party status tools are acceptable, but HMRC requires their output to meet exactly the same three criteria [2]. A step-by-step walk through the tool is in the Moonworkers CEST tool guide.

Issuing the SDS: who receives it and when

Timing and delivery matter as much as content. A correct determination that never reaches the right party still leaves the client exposed [5].

Recipients and format

The client must give the SDS to the worker and to the party it contracts with, typically an agency or the worker's own company [5]. The client is the only party required to send a copy to the worker, and the worker must be able to receive or access it, for example by email, letter or an online portal [5]. The legislation does not prescribe a format, and HMRC accepts paper or electronic statements [2].

HMRC also describes it as good practice to issue a formal SDS for every off-payroll worker, including those judged outside the rules [2]. An "outside" SDS gives the agency a documented reason to pay gross and gives the client evidence of its process if HMRC later enquires [4].

Timing and the supply chain

The SDS should be issued on or before the date of any payment [5]. Until it has been passed on, the client remains the deemed employer and must itself deduct income tax and employee National Insurance and pay employer National Insurance [4] [2].

In a longer chain, each party must forward the SDS to the party it contracts with, and any party that fails to do so becomes responsible for the tax [5]. The deemed employer is the qualifying person at the lowest point in the chain, immediately above the worker's intermediary, that holds the SDS [8] [17].

Party in the chainRole when the SDS is passed on correctlyRole when it is not
ClientIssues the SDS, handles disagreementsRemains deemed employer until it passes the SDS on
First agencyForwards the SDS; may carry residual liability if lower parties failBecomes deemed employer
Lowest qualifying agencyDeemed employer: runs PAYE on the deemed direct paymentNot applicable
Worker's intermediaryReceives payment net of tax and NIReceives gross payment

An agency that receives no SDS should pay on without deducting tax or National Insurance and can ask the party above why none was provided [17]. Offshore agencies do not count as qualifying persons, so the nearest UK agency stays responsible until the SDS reaches the UK party below [5] [8].

Contract changes and renewals

An SDS covers one engagement on the terms that existed when it was made. The client must reconsider it when there is a material change to the terms or working practices, and a new contract is a new engagement that needs a new SDS [5]. A simple extension on identical terms may not need a fresh statement [5].

Failing to reconsider after a material change is on HMRC's list of behaviours that show a lack of reasonable care [15]. CEST can be rerun to test whether a change in duties or control affects the result [16].

The client-led status disagreement process

Every client that issues an SDS must run a disagreement process. Section 61T of ITEPA 2003 sets the statutory framework [18], and HMRC's manual and Guidance for Compliance set out the minimum standards [3] [6].

Who can disagree and how

Only the worker and the deemed employer may raise a disagreement. An agency that is not the deemed employer has no right to use the process [3]. Representations can be verbal or written, and they should include reasons linked to the status indicators; the client may ask for more evidence [19] [6].

A disagreement can be raised at any point until the final payment in the chain, and there is no cap on how many times it can be raised [3]. A repeat representation with no new facts can be closed by standing by the original SDS [6].

The 45-day deadline

The client must respond within 45 calendar days, counted from the day the representations are received, not from the date of the SDS [3]. HMRC's Guidance for Compliance records one organisation that wrongly told workers they had 45 days from the date of its letter to object [6].

Outcome of the reviewWhat the client must do
The SDS is correctTell the party that it stands, with reasons
The SDS is wrongWithdraw it and issue a new SDS stating the date from which it applies
No response within 45 daysClient becomes liable for tax, NI and Apprenticeship Levy on later payments until it responds

The consequences in the table come from HMRC's manual [3] and the Guidance for Compliance [6]. The transfer of liability for a missed deadline applies whether or not the client took reasonable care [3].

Payroll during and after a dispute

While the disagreement is being considered, the deemed employer continues to apply the original SDS, operating PAYE if it says the rules apply [3] [8]. If the determination changes, corrections are made through the next Full Payment Submission or a corrective FPS with the correct year-to-date figures; deleting the worker's payroll record does not fix the position [3].

If the client-led process does not resolve the dispute, a worker can take it to HMRC only after the end of the tax year, through Self Assessment for income tax and by writing to HMRC for Class 1 National Insurance [19]. Requests made during the year are redirected to the client's process [19] [7].

How an "inside" SDS flows through payroll

When the SDS concludes that the rules apply, the deemed employer treats the fee as a deemed direct payment of employment income. The mechanics are close to an ordinary payroll run, with some important differences. A fuller explanation of what the conclusion means for the worker is in the Moonworkers guide to inside IR35 status.

Calculating the deemed direct payment

The deemed employer starts with the payment to the intermediary excluding VAT, takes off any direct cost of materials, then takes off expenses met by the intermediary that would have been deductible for an employee [8]. A nil or negative result means there is no deemed direct payment for that period [8] [20].

The deemed employer then deducts income tax and employee Class 1 National Insurance, pays employer National Insurance on top, and reports the payment on the FPS using the indicator for an off-payroll worker subject to the rules [8]. Employer National Insurance cannot be deducted from the deemed payment, the Employment Allowance cannot be set against it, and the payment counts towards the Apprenticeship Levy pay bill [8] [21].

Rates that apply

Normal rates and thresholds apply to the deemed payment, and HMRC notes that the tax code used is often BR, which taxes the whole amount at the basic rate [8]. The 2026-27 figures below come from HMRC's rates and thresholds page [22].

Item2026-27 figure
Basic rate of income tax (BR code)20%
Employee Class 1 NI, main rate8%
Employee Class 1 NI, above the upper earnings limit2%
Employer Class 1 NI rate15%
Employer secondary threshold£5,000 a year
Primary threshold£12,570 a year

Student loan and postgraduate loan deductions are not made from deemed direct payments [8]. That is one of the differences a payroll system must handle explicitly, because the worker's own student loan plan may be recorded elsewhere [22].

Worked example 1: a monthly invoice under a BR code

A contractor's company invoices an agency £5,000 for a month, excluding VAT, with no materials or allowable expenses, so the deemed direct payment is £5,000. Run on a BR code with NI category letter A, the Moonworkers engine gives income tax of £1,000.00, employee National Insurance of £267.50 and employer National Insurance of £687.45. The intermediary receives £3,732.50, and the employer National Insurance is a cost the deemed employer bears on top of the fee [8] [22].

The same £5,000 paid under a 1257L code would carry income tax of £952.06, with National Insurance unchanged, and the net would be £3,780.44. The difference shows why the tax code matters: BR gives no personal allowance, so any over-deduction is reclaimed by the worker later through Self Assessment or HMRC [8] [22].

Worked example 2: a year-long engagement

For an engagement worth £60,000 over a year, processed annually on a BR code, the engine gives income tax of £12,000.00, employee National Insurance of £3,210.60 and employer National Insurance of £8,250.00, leaving a net payment of £44,789.40 to the intermediary [22]. In practice the deemed employer runs the figures each pay period, which is why cumulative year-to-date values on the FPS must stay accurate after any correction [3].

Payroll bureaux and agencies that run deemed payments for many contractors need these rules applied consistently across clients. A payroll bureau platform that holds each worker's SDS outcome, the off-payroll indicator and the student loan suppression as data, rather than as manual steps, removes the most common sources of error.

When things go wrong: liability and set-off

The SDS rules allocate liability carefully. Knowing where it lands helps clients and agencies decide how much process to build.

Where the liability lands

A client that issued a valid SDS with reasonable care, and passed it on correctly, does not carry the tax liability even if the decision later proves wrong; responsibility sits with the deemed employer [15] [5]. Where reasonable care was not taken, the client is liable even if a fee payer has already deducted tax on the original determination [15].

Agencies are not fully insulated either. The first agency in the chain may be liable if HMRC cannot collect from the parties below it, for example where they have been dissolved without a genuine business failure [17]. The Moonworkers guide to IR35 penalties covers the penalty regime that sits alongside the tax itself.

Set-off of tax already paid

From 6 April 2024, when HMRC assesses a deemed employer for non-compliance, it can set off tax and National Insurance already paid by the worker and their intermediary on the same income [23]. The policy paper explains that amounts treated as already recovered from the worker or intermediary cannot also be recovered from the deemed employer [24].

HMRC's illustrative case study shows the scale. Three engagements of £60,000 each created a gross PAYE liability of £64,989; after a set-off of £15,087 for corporation tax and income tax already paid, the net liability was £49,902 [25]. The set-off reduces the bill but does not remove it, and amounts used in a set-off cannot later be repaid to the worker [23].

Records and controls for an SDS process

A defensible process rests on records. HMRC's guidance for clients lists what should be kept, and normal document retention rules apply to the SDS itself [4] [5].

What to keep

RecordWhy it matters
Each determination with its reasonsShows the three validity criteria were met
Evidence of reasonable care (CEST output, advice, reviewer)Protects the client from inheriting liability
Date and method of issue to the worker and contracted partyProves the SDS was passed on before payment
Disagreements received and responses, with datesProves the 45-day deadline was met
Names and addresses of contractors and intermediariesRequired by HMRC and needed for set-off claims
Fees paid under each engagementLinks the SDS to the payments it governs

The list draws on HMRC's client guidance [4] and the manual's reasonable care examples [15].

Building the process into systems

Clients with many contractors tend to embed the SDS step into onboarding: no purchase order or timesheet is approved until a determination exists and has been issued [2]. Contract change events then trigger a review, and disagreement tickets carry a 45-day timer from the day of receipt [3].

For workforce, vendor management and HR platforms, the payroll side of this flow can be automated. An HMRC-recognised payroll API lets a platform submit the deemed direct payment, apply the off-payroll indicator and file the FPS without building PAYE logic in-house. Smaller clients that engage contractors through umbrella arrangements face different rules, covered in the guide to umbrella company payroll.

Size the deductions on a deemed payment

Before agreeing a day rate on an inside engagement, the deemed employer and the worker can both size the deductions with the Moonworkers UK salary calculator, which applies the 2026-27 PAYE and National Insurance rules to any gross amount and pay period.

£ per month

£

e.g. 1257L, S1257L, BR, D0

S = Scotland · C = Wales · W1/M1 = non-cumulative

Enter a salary or hourly rate above

About this calculator

This calculator gives you a close estimate of your UK payroll deductions for 2026-27, using HMRC's exact percentage method with periodised thresholds. It handles the three tax territories, K codes with the 50% regulatory limit and its carry-forward, weeks 53, 54 and 56, the cumulative and W1/M1/X bases, student and postgraduate loans, and pension contributions on qualifying earnings. It still won't match your payslip to the penny in every case: it does not cover in-year tax code changes, payrolled benefits in kind, NI deferral across more than one employment, directors on the annual earnings period, or employer-level annual adjustments such as the Employment Allowance and the apprenticeship levy. Powered by the same engine as the Moonworkers Payroll API.

Run real payroll

Frequently asked questions

Why might the result differ from my payslip?

This calculator uses your current gross pay and tax code to produce an estimate. K-code carry-forwards and weeks 53, 54 and 56 are handled, and the Year-to-date section reproduces a specific period exactly. What your employer may apply that this does not: a mid-year tax code change, benefits in kind processed through payroll, or NI deferral across more than one employment. For most employees on a standard tax code the difference is negligible.

What tax code should I enter?

Use the tax code shown on your most recent payslip or the PAYE Coding Notice (P2) from HMRC. If you're not sure, 1257L is the standard code for most employees resident in England, Wales, or Northern Ireland. Use S1257L for Scotland or C1257L for Wales if you pay Scottish or Welsh income tax.

Which NI category applies to me?

Most employees use Category A. Use M if you are under 21, H if you are an apprentice under 25, or C if you are over State Pension age. Your employer is responsible for assigning the correct category. If in doubt, check your payslip.

Which student loan plan am I on?

Your plan depends on when and where you studied. Plan 1 covers students who started before September 2012. Plan 2 is for English and Welsh students who started from September 2012 to July 2023. Plan 5 applies to English students who started from August 2023. Plan 4 covers Scottish students. You can check your plan at gov.uk or on your payslip.

What is the YTD cumulative PAYE mode?

HMRC's standard method calculates income tax on your total earnings to date each period, then subtracts tax already paid. If you're mid-year and want to see exactly what tax should be deducted in a specific period, expand the Year-to-date section and enter your running totals from previous periods only.

Conclusion

The status determination statement turns the off-payroll working rules from an abstract test into a concrete document with deadlines, recipients and consequences. Its value depends less on the conclusion than on the reasoning and the care behind it: a well-reasoned "inside" or "outside" SDS, passed down the chain before the first payment, protects the client, while a blanket or late statement leaves liability where the client least expects it.

As HMRC's guidance on reasonable care and set-off has matured, the direction is clear. Status decisions are judged on evidence, disagreements on deadlines, and payroll on accurate RTI data. Organisations that treat the SDS as a data point in their systems, rather than a letter in a folder, are best placed to show compliance when HMRC asks.

Frequently asked questions

Does a small company client need to issue a status determination statement?

No. A small private sector client does not determine status, so it issues no SDS; the worker's intermediary decides whether the rules apply and accounts for any tax. The client must, however, confirm its size if asked by the worker or an agency [7] [17].

Can a CEST result be used as the status determination statement?

Yes. HMRC states that the saved answers and result from CEST can be used as a valid SDS, provided the information entered is accurate and the tool is used in line with HMRC guidance [16]. Issuing the output shows that the client agrees with it, and the reasons still need to be understandable to the worker [1].

What happens if the client does not answer a disagreement within 45 days?

The client becomes liable for the income tax, National Insurance and Apprenticeship Levy on payments made after the deadline until it responds. This applies regardless of whether the original determination was made with reasonable care [3] [6].

Are student loan repayments deducted from an inside IR35 payment?

No. HMRC's guidance for deemed employers states that student loan and postgraduate loan deductions are not made from deemed direct payments. Income tax and employee and employer Class 1 National Insurance are still applied at the normal rates [8] [22].