Assess a worker for auto-enrolment
Eligible, non-eligible or entitled: the 2026-27 thresholds and minimum contributions.
This article was written with the help of AI.
UK pension tax relief is worth up to 100% of a member's annual earnings [1], and HMRC estimates the gross cost of pension Income Tax and National Insurance relief at £83.9 billion for 2024 to 2025 [16]. In a workplace scheme, that relief reaches employees through one of two payroll methods: relief at source or net pay.
The two methods are not a payroll setting the employer picks per employee. HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual is clear that the method is fixed by the scheme, and that a member cannot choose it [3]. Under net pay, the employer deducts the contribution before tax; under relief at source, the employer deducts it after tax and the provider claims basic-rate relief from HMRC [1].
For most basic-rate taxpayers the end result is identical, but the methods diverge sharply for low earners, higher-rate taxpayers and Scottish taxpayers. They also change what goes into each Full Payment Submission. This guide compares the two methods step by step, with worked examples recalculated on the 2026-27 rules, and sets out the low earner pension payment, the reporting fields and the errors that follow from running the wrong method.
Key takeaways
- Under net pay, the contribution comes off gross pay before PAYE, so relief is given automatically at the employee's highest rate of tax.
- Under relief at source, the employer deducts 80% of the gross contribution from net pay and the provider claims the 20% basic-rate relief from HMRC.
- A basic-rate taxpayer pays the same net cost under either method; a non-taxpayer gains under relief at source, and a higher-rate taxpayer has to claim extra relief under it.
- Neither method reduces National Insurance: only salary sacrifice changes the NI position.
- On the FPS, net pay contributions reduce taxable pay and are reported separately from relief at source deductions taken from net pay.
How pension tax relief works in a workplace scheme
Tax relief on member contributions is available up to the greater of £3,600 and the member's relevant UK earnings for the tax year [6]. The relief applies in the tax year the contribution is paid and cannot be carried back or forward [6]. Employer contributions do not count towards the member's own relief, a point HMRC sets out among the essential principles of pension contributions [19] [20].
Three methods, two of them in payroll
HMRC recognises three ways of giving relief: relief at source, where the scheme recovers basic-rate tax from HMRC and adds it to the fund; net pay, where the employer deducts the contribution from gross pay before tax; and claims, where the member pays gross and claims relief through Self Assessment [3]. Only the first two run through payroll, and they are the subject of this comparison.
HMRC's own manual notes that, for most people, these methods produce an identical level of tax relief [6]. The differences lie at the edges of the tax system: below the Personal Allowance, above the basic-rate band and in Scotland.
Why the scheme, not the employer, decides
Schemes must operate relief at source unless their rules allow net pay or gross payments [4]. Net pay is available to occupational schemes where all employee members of the same employer use it [5], and HMRC states that an employer cannot split its employees between the two methods [5].
The Pensions Regulator gives the same message to employers choosing an auto-enrolment scheme: a scheme can use only one method for all staff, and staff are affected differently under each [11]. That makes the tax relief method one of the selection criteria when the employer picks a scheme, rather than a payroll switch to flip later.
Net pay arrangement: relief through PAYE
Under a net pay arrangement, the employer deducts the contribution from gross pay and operates PAYE on what remains, which gives full relief at the member's marginal rate [5].
How the deduction is processed
The payroll order matters. The contribution is taken before income tax is calculated, so taxable pay falls by the full contribution. HMRC's employer guidance treats the contribution as deductible for PAYE but not for National Insurance, so NI is still calculated on the full gross pay [18]. No further relief is due through the tax code, because the deduction before tax has already given it [14].
Who net pay suits, and its limits
Because relief follows the marginal rate, a higher-rate or additional-rate taxpayer receives full relief immediately, with no claim to make [5]. The arrangement only works for employees of the sponsoring employer: former employees and third-party contributions cannot go through net pay [5].
Relief can also fall short when contributions exceed the employment income from which they are deducted. HMRC's example is an employee earning £24,000 who pays 10% monthly, whose bonus month produces a contribution larger than the salary it is taken from; the excess relief is then claimed through Self Assessment [7] [5].
Relief at source: relief through the provider
Under relief at source, the member pays contributions net of basic-rate tax and the scheme administrator claims the relief from HMRC and adds it to the pot [3].
How the deduction is processed
The employer runs PAYE and National Insurance on full gross pay, then deducts the member's net contribution from net pay. HMRC's own illustration is a member who wants £100 a month in the pension: the member pays £80 and the scheme claims £20 at the 20% basic rate [4]. All personal and stakeholder pensions and some workplace pensions use this method [1].
Scheme administrators make interim claims on form APSS 105, covering up to three tax months with a £50 minimum, and an annual claim on APSS 106 [4]. The employer has no part in those claims, which is one reason relief at source is simple to run in payroll.
Higher-rate taxpayers must claim the rest
Relief at source only delivers the basic rate. In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, a member taxed at 40% claims a further 20% on the income taxed at that rate, and a member taxed at 45% claims a further 25% [1]. The claim is made through the Self Assessment return or, for those outside Self Assessment, through HMRC's online service, which adjusts the tax code [2] [14].
HMRC says it will review an online claim and respond within 28 working days [2]. Relief that is never claimed is simply lost to the member, which is the main practical weakness of relief at source for better-paid staff.
Non-taxpayers and the £2,880 rule
Relief at source pays basic-rate relief whether or not the member pays tax. The provider can claim 20% on contributions up to 80% of the year's earnings, or on up to £2,880 for someone with no earnings [1]. Where earnings are below £3,600, relief on contributions above earnings is only available under relief at source [6].
Side-by-side comparison
The table below summarises the mechanics of the two methods [1] [3].
| Feature | Net pay arrangement | Relief at source |
|---|---|---|
| When the deduction is taken | Before income tax | After income tax and NI |
| Who gives the relief | The employer, through PAYE | The provider, claiming from HMRC |
| Rate of relief given automatically | The member's marginal rate | Basic rate only |
| Effect on National Insurance | None | None |
| Non-taxpayers | No relief through payroll | 20% added to the pot |
| Higher and additional-rate taxpayers | Full relief automatically | Must claim the extra relief |
| Typical scheme type | Occupational, trust-based | Personal, stakeholder, group personal |
The Pensions Regulator's scheme guidance lists Nest and, by default, The People's Pension among relief at source schemes, and Smart Pension among net pay schemes [11] [10]. Group personal pensions always use relief at source [10].
Worked examples on the 2026-27 rules
The three examples below use a standard 1257L tax code in England, an annual salary and a member contribution of 5% of total salary, with the 2026-27 income tax bands [21] and employee National Insurance rates [22]. Auto-enrolment minimums are calculated on qualifying earnings between £6,240 and £50,270 [12]; using total salary here keeps the arithmetic transparent. Income tax and NI figures were calculated with the Moonworkers payroll engine.
Basic-rate taxpayer on £30,000
The employee earns £30,000 and the scheme receives £1,500 in total. Under net pay, taxable pay falls to £28,500, on which income tax is £3,184.20, while National Insurance stays at £1,394.40 because it is charged on the full £30,000 [18]. Under relief at source, income tax on £30,000 is £3,484.20 and the take-home pay before the pension deduction is £25,121.40; the employee then pays £1,200 and the provider adds £300 at the 20% basic rate [4].
| Line | Net pay arrangement | Relief at source |
|---|---|---|
| Gross salary | £30,000 | £30,000 |
| Income tax | £3,184.20 | £3,484.20 |
| Employee NI | £1,394.40 | £1,394.40 |
| Employee's own pension deduction | £1,500 | £1,200 |
| Take-home pay | £23,921.40 | £23,921.40 |
| Total into the pension | £1,500 | £1,500 |
The result is identical: the £300 of relief is given either as lower income tax or as a top-up from the provider. This is the case HMRC has in mind when it describes the two methods as giving an identical level of relief for most people [6].
Higher-rate taxpayer on £60,000
At £60,000 the employee pays £3,000 into the pension. Under net pay, taxable pay falls to £57,000, on which income tax is £10,228.40 instead of £11,428.40, so the full £1,200 of relief at 40% arrives through PAYE with no further action [5]. National Insurance stays at £3,210.60 under both methods.
Under relief at source, the employee pays £2,400 from net pay and the provider adds £600. The remaining £600 is only received if the employee claims the extra 20% on the income taxed at 40%, through Self Assessment or a tax code adjustment [1] [2]. HMRC's statistics show that 57% of Income Tax relief on pension contributions is given at the higher rate [16], which is why unclaimed higher-rate relief is a recurring issue.
Low earner on £12,000
At £12,000 the employee earns below the £12,570 Personal Allowance and pays no income tax [21]. A 5% contribution is £600. Under net pay, deducting it before tax changes nothing, because there was no tax to reduce, so the employee bears the full £600 [8]. Under relief at source, the employee pays £480 and the provider still adds £120 [1].
That £120 gap is the low earner anomaly. HMRC's policy paper describes it directly: relief at source members get a 20% top-up even if they pay no income tax, while net pay members receive relief at their marginal rate, which can be 0% [8].
The low earner pension payment
Parliament addressed the anomaly with a new section 193A of the Finance Act 2004, operative from 6 April 2024 [8].
Who qualifies and how it is paid
The payment goes to people saving into a net pay scheme whose taxable income is below or around the Personal Allowance and who received no relief on their contributions [5]. Eligibility is calculated after each tax year from 2024 to 2025 onwards, and members do not apply: HMRC identifies them from its own data and contacts them directly [5] [9]. The payment itself is chargeable to income tax [8].
Scale, amounts and timing
HMRC's January 2025 newsletter estimated approximately one million eligible individuals, receiving an annual payment of around £70, and said payments for 2024 to 2025 were likely to be offered later than planned [15]. The policy paper put the number at an estimated 1.2 million and the operational cost at around £38 million [8].
The payment does not affect benefits or National Insurance, and administrators were told the impact on them would be minimal [15]. The policy paper estimates that women make up 75% of those eligible [8].
What it means for employers
Employers take no action for the payment. It is paid by HMRC after the end of the tax year, so a low-paid net pay member still sees no relief on the payslip itself [9] [11]. For a workforce with many part-time or low-paid staff, that timing difference remains a factor in scheme choice. The broader mechanics are set out in the guide to pension contributions tax relief.
Scottish taxpayers under each method
Scotland's six income tax bands, from the 19% starter rate to the 48% top rate [23], make the comparison less symmetrical than in the rest of the UK.
Relief at source in Scotland
Since 6 April 2016, relief at source is claimed at the Scottish basic rate for Scottish taxpayers [4]. A starter-rate taxpayer still gets 20% relief from the provider and does not pay back the difference from the 19% starter rate [1] [4]. Members taxed above the basic rate claim the balance through Self Assessment, as set out below [1].
| Scottish rate paid | Extra relief claimed on that slice |
|---|---|
| Intermediate rate, 21% | 1% |
| Higher rate, 42% | 22% |
| Advanced rate, 45% | 25% |
| Top rate, 48% | 28% |
Net pay in Scotland and residency status
Under net pay, Scottish taxpayers receive relief at their Scottish marginal rate automatically, because PAYE runs on the reduced pay [5]. For relief at source, administrators rely on HMRC's residency status reports: once a status has been used for a member it applies for the whole tax year, and the member's address must not be used to set the rate [15]. HMRC's coding guidance confirms that the pension company is told the correct basic rate, with any change of status corrected through reconciliation [14].
How each method is reported on the FPS
The two methods use different data items on the Full Payment Submission, and mixing them up is a common source of incorrect taxable pay.
Net pay contributions reduce taxable pay
HMRC's RTI data item guide defines taxable pay as all pay minus authorised deductions under net pay arrangements, so a net pay contribution never appears in taxable pay to date [17]. The contribution itself is reported in its own fields: the value of employee contributions paid under net pay arrangements in the pay period, and the same figure year to date [17].
Relief at source contributions sit in deductions from net pay
A relief at source contribution is taken after tax, so taxable pay is unchanged. The guide lists pension contributions not paid under a net pay arrangement as an example of deductions from net pay, and has a separate field for the value of employee contributions not paid under a net pay arrangement, per period and year to date [17]. Once a year-to-date amount is sent, it must be supplied for the rest of the tax year [17].
The table below maps each method to its reporting treatment.
| FPS item | Net pay arrangement | Relief at source |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable pay | Reduced by the contribution | Not reduced |
| Contributions under net pay arrangements | Reported | Blank |
| Contributions not under a net pay arrangement | Blank | Reported |
| Deductions from net pay | Excludes the contribution | Includes the contribution |
A payroll engine has to apply this mapping on every run and for every scheme, which is where an HMRC-recognised payroll API carries the rule centrally rather than leaving it to manual configuration. The field-level detail is in the API documentation.
When the wrong method is used
Because the method belongs to the scheme, an error usually starts with a payroll set-up that does not match the scheme's rules. The Pensions Regulator sets out what follows in each direction [10].
The two directions of error
Where net pay was used instead of relief at source, the employee received too much relief through PAYE and has very likely underpaid tax, and HMRC will look to the employer to put this right [10]. Where relief at source was used instead of net pay, the contributions paid are too low, and the employer is expected to make up the shortfall [10]. HMRC's manual adds that relief may not be given by net pay where relief at source is already in use [4].
Correcting the error
The regulator's steps are to talk to the provider, correct the method going forward, establish how far back the error goes and who is affected, agree a timescale and tell employees [10]. HMRC may need to be involved, particularly where several tax years are affected, and the employer should notify the regulator [10]. Bureaux that run many schemes can lower the risk by recording the method against each scheme in a multi-client payroll dashboard and checking it at every onboarding.
Choosing a scheme with the method in mind
The relief method is one factor among several when an employer selects an auto-enrolment scheme. The minimum contributions are 8% of qualifying earnings in total, of which at least 3% comes from the employer [12], and those minimums apply under either method. Every employer must enrol eligible staff into a qualifying scheme [24], and the regulator's employer guidance covers the assessment and enrolment steps [25]. The guide to auto-enrolment covers the wider duties.
Workforce profile and salary sacrifice
A workforce dominated by staff below the Personal Allowance gains on the payslip from relief at source, while one with many higher-rate earners gains from the automatic relief of net pay [11] [1]. Salary sacrifice is a third route: the regulator notes that non-taxpayers receive no tax relief under it, whichever method the scheme uses [11]. All contributions, including the employer's, also count towards the annual allowance, which HMRC sets at £60,000 [13].
Running either method in payroll
Both methods need the same core data in payroll: the scheme's method, the contribution basis and each employee's pay. Under net pay the payroll reduces taxable pay before PAYE [5]; under relief at source it deducts the net contribution after tax and leaves the claim to the provider [4]. Moonworkers' UK payroll software applies the method per scheme and produces the matching FPS fields [17].
Check auto-enrolment contributions
Before choosing a scheme, an employer can test how contributions fall for each employee with the Moonworkers auto-enrolment calculator, which applies the 2026-27 qualifying earnings band and minimum rates.
Age decides the category: 22 to State Pension age for automatic enrolment, 16 to 74 for opt-in and joining rights. We work out their State Pension age from the statutory timetable.
Assessment result
No assessment yet
Two quick steps: the worker's date of birth, then their pay. The category and minimum contributions appear here.
Auto-enrolment on autopilot
Moonworkers assesses every worker on every payrun, handles enrolment, opt-outs and re-enrolment, and pushes contributions to NEST, Smart Pension and The People's Pension automatically.
Conclusion
Relief at source and net pay deliver the same relief for the typical basic-rate employee, so the choice only becomes visible at the margins: the part-time worker below the Personal Allowance, the higher-rate earner who never claims, and the Scottish taxpayer on a band with no exact match. The low earner pension payment narrows the first gap, but only after the tax year and outside payroll.
For payroll teams, the more immediate point is that the method is a property of the scheme and flows straight into taxable pay and the FPS. As more benefits and reporting move into real time, getting the method right at scheme set-up, and holding it consistently across every pay run, is what keeps employees' relief and HMRC's records aligned.
Frequently asked questions
Is relief at source or net pay better for a basic-rate taxpayer?
For a basic-rate taxpayer the two methods give the same result. Under net pay the relief appears as lower income tax; under relief at source it appears as a 20% top-up from the provider [4]. HMRC's manual describes the methods as giving an identical level of relief for most people [6].
Can an employer use net pay for some employees and relief at source for others?
No. The method is fixed by the scheme, and an employer cannot split its employees between the two within a scheme [5]. The Pensions Regulator confirms that a scheme uses only one method for all staff [11].
How does a higher-rate taxpayer claim extra relief under relief at source?
The member claims the extra relief through the Self Assessment return, or through HMRC's online service if they do not file one [2]. HMRC usually gives the relief by adjusting the tax code [14]. Evidence of the contributions, such as a provider statement, is needed for each tax year claimed.
Does net pay reduce National Insurance contributions?
No. Net pay contributions are deducted from pay before income tax but not before National Insurance, so NI is calculated on full gross pay [18]. Relief at source does not reduce NI either. Only a salary sacrifice arrangement changes the pay on which NI is charged [11].



