Moonworkers
Blog

CIS verification: how contractors check subcontractors

CIS verification explained: when a contractor must verify a subcontractor with HMRC, the details needed, what an unmatched result means and how it is recorded.

CIS verification: how contractors check subcontractors

This article was written with the help of AI.

Under the Construction Industry Scheme, a contractor must verify a new subcontractor with HMRC before the first payment, and that check decides whether the deduction is 20%, 30% or nothing at all [1] [2]. A subcontractor last included on a return in the current or previous 2 tax years does not need verifying again [1].

Verification is the step that turns a name on an invoice into a tax treatment. HMRC confirms whether the subcontractor is registered for CIS and which rate applies, or whether the payment can be made gross [1]. Every later CIS obligation, from the payment and deduction statement to the monthly return, depends on that answer being right.

Errors at this stage are expensive in both directions. A contractor that deducts too little remains liable for the shortfall, while a subcontractor wrongly treated as unverified suffers the higher rate and waits for a refund. This guide sets out when verification is required, the information HMRC expects for each type of business, how to read the verification reference, what happens when a subcontractor is unmatched, and the reforms from 6 April 2026 that changed the surrounding rules.

Key takeaways

  • A contractor verifies every new subcontractor with HMRC before paying them, online or through commercial CIS software.
  • Re-verification is only needed when the subcontractor has not appeared on the contractor's CIS return in the current or previous 2 tax years.
  • The details supplied must exactly match those the subcontractor used to register, or HMRC returns an unmatched result.
  • An unmatched subcontractor is paid under the 30% higher rate, and the verification reference carries a letter suffix that must appear on the monthly return.
  • From 6 April 2026, payments to local authorities and certain public bodies fall outside CIS, so those bodies are not verified at all.

What CIS verification is and why it exists

The Construction Industry Scheme sets out how contractors handle payments to subcontractors for construction work, with deductions passed to HMRC as advance payments towards the subcontractor's tax and National Insurance [18]. Verification is the gatekeeping step that tells the contractor which of three treatments applies before any money moves.

The legal basis for the check

HMRC's manual places the duty in regulation 6 of the Income Tax (Construction Industry Scheme) Regulations 2005, which requires a contractor to verify whether a subcontractor is registered for payment under deduction or for gross payment [5]. The contractor guidance repeats the rule in plain terms: before paying a new subcontractor, the contractor checks them with HMRC [1].

The obligation sits alongside the other core contractor duties listed by HMRC: registering before taking on the first subcontractor, checking whether a worker should really be an employee, deducting and paying over the money, and filing monthly returns [4]. Verification is the second link in that chain, and a gap in it undermines every later step.

Who counts as a contractor

A business that pays subcontractors for construction work is a mainstream contractor. A business outside construction becomes a deemed contractor once it has spent more than £3 million on construction in the 12 months since its first such payment [4]. The CIS340 guide uses the same £3 million test for deemed contractors [17].

The work itself must fall inside the scheme. Site preparation, demolition, building, alterations, repairs, decorating and the installation of heating, lighting, power, water and ventilation systems are covered, while architecture, surveying, scaffolding hire without labour, carpet fitting and delivering materials are not [18]. A contractor that pays only for excluded work has nothing to verify.

When a contractor must verify a subcontractor

The rule is simple to state and easy to misapply on a busy site. Verification is about the relationship between one contractor scheme and one subcontractor, not about the subcontractor's status in general.

New subcontractors and the 2-tax-year rule

A contractor verifies a subcontractor before the first payment. After that, the check is only repeated if the subcontractor has not been included on one of the contractor's CIS returns in the current tax year or either of the 2 previous tax years [1] [5]. Within that window, the contractor pays on the same basis as the last payment unless HMRC has said otherwise [17].

HMRC's verification overview adds that a payment status can continue for an indefinite period unless HMRC advises a change [8]. The subcontractor-facing manual page makes the same point: no fresh check is needed where the subcontractor has worked for that contractor within the window [6].

The table below summarises the common situations.

SituationVerify before paying?Source
Brand-new subcontractorYes[1]
On a CIS return in the current or previous 2 tax yearsNo[5]
Last on a return more than 2 tax years agoYes[1]
Already verified by another company in the same group within the windowNo[6]
Local authority or certain public body, from 6 April 2026No, outside CIS[17]

Group companies and divisions

Groups get a practical concession. A company does not need to verify a subcontractor that another company in the same group has already verified within the current or previous 2 tax years [5]. The CIS340 guide covers the same group rule in its verification chapter [17].

Divisions of a single contractor that run separate CIS schemes may share verification details, but HMRC requires the payments themselves to be kept separate on each scheme [8]. Verification also only works against an active contractor scheme, so a scheme that has been merged, superseded or transferred out cannot be used to run a check [8].

Before the check: contract and employment status

HMRC expects a formal arrangement to exist before verification. Its overview says the contractor must confirm that a tender, signed contract or work order is in place before the payment is made [8], and its staff procedure reminds contractors that every monthly return carries a declaration that the subcontractors listed are self-employed [9].

That declaration has teeth. A contractor that gives the wrong employment status on a monthly return faces a penalty of up to £3,000 [3]. HMRC's employment status tool is the usual first check where the line between employee and subcontractor is unclear [20]. A worker who is in fact an employee belongs on the payroll, not on the CIS return, and the business then needs HMRC-recognised payroll software for SMEs to run PAYE for that person.

The information HMRC needs for each business type

HMRC matches the details supplied against the record the subcontractor created at registration. The contractor guidance is explicit that the details must exactly match those the subcontractor used to register [1].

The contractor's own references

The contractor identifies its own scheme with three references: its Unique Taxpayer Reference, its HMRC Accounts Office reference number and its employer reference [1]. The online route requires the contractor to sign in to its business tax account with CIS added to it [19].

The subcontractor's details

What the contractor supplies about the subcontractor depends on the legal form of the business, as the table below shows [1].

Subcontractor typeDetails requiredManual reference
Sole traderUTR and National Insurance number, plus name[9]
PartnershipPartnership UTR, trading name and the nominated partner's details[11]
Limited companyCompany name, company UTR and company registration number[10]
TrustTrust details as registered[21]

Two traps recur. Temporary National Insurance numbers, which start with "TN" or 2 digits, cannot be used for verification [1]. For a partnership, entering only the partnership UTR prompts HMRC's system to ask which partner is being verified, and the partner's own UTR, National Insurance number or company registration number completes the match [11].

What the subcontractor should supply

The subcontractor guidance tells subcontractors to give the contractor the exact details they used at registration, namely their UTR and their legal business or trading name, and warns that a failed verification can affect how much they are paid [13]. A subcontractor that has never registered can do so before starting work, which avoids the higher rate from the first invoice [22]. The guide to CIS subcontractor registration covers that process.

How to verify: online service, software and volumes

HMRC offers two channels and sets a clear volume limit. A contractor can use the free HMRC CIS online service or commercial CIS software, but anyone verifying more than 50 subcontractors must use commercial software [1].

The online service

The CIS online service lets a contractor both verify subcontractors and file monthly returns [19]. HMRC notes that the service may be slow at busy times [19], which matters in the days before the 19th of the month, when monthly returns fall due [3]. Running verification as part of onboarding, rather than on payday, keeps the two workloads apart.

Commercial software and batch checks

Commercial CIS software is one of the two verification channels HMRC accepts, and the only one for volumes above 50 subcontractors [1]. It stores the result against the subcontractor record. HMRC's manual notes that a monthly return can be pre-populated with verified subcontractors who have not yet been paid [23], which is one reason a stored verification history saves time later. For platforms that already hold subcontractor data, an HMRC-recognised payroll API can carry that history alongside PAYE records so the two do not drift apart.

Telephone requests handled by HMRC staff

HMRC's internal procedure still covers verification requests handled by its own staff. Where a contractor asks for more than 10 subcontractors to be verified in one contact, the case is passed to the CIS Centre in Newcastle for a call back [9] [10]. The online and software channels remain the routes HMRC directs contractors to [1].

Reading the result: rates and the verification reference

Each verification returns a tax treatment and a reference. Both have to be carried through to the contractor's records, statements and returns.

The three possible treatments

HMRC's answer leads to one of three deduction rates [2] [13].

Verification outcomeDeduction on labourTypical cause
Registered for gross payment0%Subcontractor holds gross payment status
Registered and matched20% (standard rate)Normal registered subcontractor
Not registered, or details do not match30% (higher rate)Unregistered, or mismatch in name or reference

HMRC's manual describes the same split in terms of the standard rate and the higher rate, with the higher rate applying where HMRC cannot trace the subcontractor's record [6]. Gross payment status depends on separate business, compliance and turnover tests, including a £30,000 turnover threshold for a sole trader [14], set out in more detail in the guide to CIS gross payment status.

The verification number

A successful verification produces a unique verification number in the format V followed by 10 digits, for example V1234567890, and one number covers all subcontractors verified in the same contact [8]. The CIS340 guide confirms that subcontractors verified together share a single reference [17].

When a check fails, HMRC adds a letter suffix to the number. The manual shows examples such as V1234567890/A and V1234567890/AA, and the suffixed reference must appear on the monthly return [7] [9]. It is the suffix, not the subcontractor's name, that links the higher-rate payments to the right record later.

A worked example of the deduction

The rate applies only to the labour element. Before applying it, the contractor removes VAT, consumable stores, fuel other than for travelling, plant hire, manufactured or prefabricated materials, and materials the subcontractor bought directly [2]. The table below shows an invoice of £6,000 before VAT, of which £1,500 is materials the subcontractor paid for, under each verification outcome.

LineGross statusMatched (20%)Unmatched (30%)
Invoice before VAT£6,000£6,000£6,000
Less materials£1,500£1,500£1,500
Labour element£4,500£4,500£4,500
CIS withheld and passed to HMRC£0£900£1,350
Paid to subcontractor£6,000£5,100£4,650

The £450 gap between the matched and unmatched columns is not a penalty. It is still an advance payment towards the subcontractor's tax and National Insurance [18], but it ties up cash until the subcontractor's return is settled, which is why a correct match on the first check matters to both parties.

Unmatched subcontractors and how the record is fixed

An unmatched result is not a dead end. It is a holding position that lasts until the subcontractor's identity is confirmed and a CIS record exists.

What an unmatched result means

HMRC tells the contractor that the subcontractor is not registered for CIS, that payment is possible only under the higher rate of deduction, and that the subcontractor should contact HMRC for an identity check so a record can be set up [7]. Where a UTR or National Insurance number matches but the name does not, or two references conflict, HMRC staff mark the case as suspect [9].

Most unmatched results come from small data problems rather than fraud: a trading name entered instead of the registered name, a transposed digit in a UTR, or a company verified with a sole trader's details. Checking the details against what the subcontractor registered with, before running the request again, resolves many cases [1].

When the subcontractor later registers

Once the subcontractor registers, HMRC issues a confirmation and a notice of the change of tax treatment, and the unique verification reference stays on the record so the unmatched period can be linked to the subcontractor's UTR [7]. The contractor normally needs to do nothing: HMRC's manual says the contractor will receive a notification of the change [12].

From that point the contractor applies the new rate. HMRC's manual also covers re-verification initiated by the subcontractor after registration [24], and a separate procedure for updating unmatched cases at the contractor's request [25].

Tracing a lost verification number

A contractor that asks HMRC to re-check an unmatched case supplies the original verification number, and a match becomes possible once the subcontractor holds a UTR, National Insurance number or company registration number [12]. If the number has been lost, HMRC can trace it from the employer scheme or Accounts Office reference and an approximate date [12], using the find-verifications procedure in its manual [26]. If no match is found, the higher rate continues [12].

How verification feeds statements and monthly returns

Verification is only useful if its result travels with every payment. Two documents carry it: the payment and deduction statement and the monthly return.

Payment and deduction statements

A contractor gives each subcontractor a statement within 14 days of the end of each tax month, so a payment in the tax month 6 May to 5 June needs a statement by 19 June [2]. Subcontractors are told to keep these statements, and to write to HMRC if a contractor will not provide them [13].

The CIS340 guide lists the verification number among the details a statement shows [17]. Failing to give statements or keep records can lead to a penalty of up to £3,000 [17].

The monthly return and its penalties

The monthly return is due by the 19th of the month following the end of each tax month, and the contractor declares on it that the subcontractors listed are not employees [3]. Unmatched subcontractors must be shown with their suffixed verification reference [7]. The late-filing penalties are set out below [3].

How late the return isPenalty
1 day£100
2 months£200
6 months£300 or 5% of the CIS deductions on the return, whichever is higher
12 months£300 or 5% of the CIS deductions, whichever is higher, with a possible further penalty

The full return process, including corrections, is covered in the guide to the CIS monthly return.

Inactivity and nil returns

A contractor that expects to make no payments for up to 6 months can ask HMRC to treat the scheme as inactive [2]. Without that request, a nil return is required for any month with no subcontractor payments [3]. When payments restart, verification rules apply as normal, including the 2-tax-year window.

Reforms from 6 April 2026 that touch verification

Two packages announced at Budget 2025 took effect from 6 April 2026. Neither rewrites the verification procedure, but both change who is verified and what a wrong answer costs.

Public bodies leave the scheme, nil returns return

The simplification measure takes payments to local authorities and certain public bodies out of CIS from 6 April 2026, replacing an extra-statutory concession [15]. The CIS340 guide states that contractors should not verify such bodies, make deductions from their payments or include them on returns [17].

The same measure reinstates nil returns, which had been removed in 2015: a contractor must file one for any month without subcontractor payments unless HMRC was told in advance, or face a penalty without a reasonable excuse [15]. More complete filing gives HMRC a fuller picture when it cross-checks verification data against payments [3].

Fraud measures raise the stakes on due diligence

The fraud package lets HMRC cancel gross payment status immediately where a business knew, or should have known, that a transaction was connected with fraudulent evasion [16]. The business becomes liable for the lost tax, a penalty of 30% of that tax can be charged to the business and its directors, and the wait before reapplying rises from one year to 5 years [16].

Verification alone does not prove a supply chain is clean, but a documented check, a signed contract and a clear record of each payment are the first evidence a contractor can show. These measures build on the strengthened gross payment status tests introduced from 6 April 2024 [27].

Building verification into payroll and CIS workflows

Many construction businesses run CIS for subcontractors and PAYE for directly employed staff in the same month. Verification sits at the point where a worker enters the business, which is also where the employment status decision is made [4].

A reliable workflow treats verification as an onboarding step: collect the registered name and references, run the check, store the verification number with the date, and only then release the first payment [1]. Records must be kept for at least 3 years after the end of the tax year they relate to [17]. Bureaux that manage several construction clients can run the same routine from a multi-client payroll dashboard, and the wider interaction between the two regimes is set out in the guide to payroll for construction businesses running CIS.

Conclusion

CIS verification looks like a one-line check, but it fixes the tax treatment of every payment that follows. The 2-tax-year window, the exact-match rule and the suffixed reference for unmatched subcontractors are the three details that decide whether a contractor's statements, returns and HMRC's records agree.

The direction of travel is towards tighter scrutiny of construction supply chains, with nil returns restored and harsher consequences for businesses linked to fraud. Contractors that treat verification as a documented onboarding step, rather than a payday task, are best placed for that environment, and the same discipline makes a subcontractor's eventual refund or gross payment application far smoother.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a CIS verification last?

A verification has no fixed expiry date. Once a subcontractor has been included on a contractor's CIS return, the contractor does not need to verify them again as long as they appear on a return in the current or previous 2 tax years. If they drop out of that window, a new verification is needed before the next payment [1] [5].

Can a contractor pay a subcontractor before verification comes back?

The contractor guidance requires verification before a new subcontractor is paid. Where verification fails or the subcontractor is not registered, payment can still be made, but under the 30% higher rate of deduction [2]. The suffixed verification reference must then be shown on the monthly return [7].

What does the letter at the end of a CIS verification number mean?

A letter suffix, such as /A, shows that the subcontractor could not be matched to an HMRC record. The contractor deducts at the higher rate and quotes the full suffixed reference on the monthly return. Once the subcontractor registers, HMRC links the unmatched period to the new record and notifies the contractor of the change in tax treatment [7] [12].

Does a subcontractor with gross payment status still need verifying?

Yes. Verification is how the contractor learns that gross payment status applies in the first place, so a new subcontractor with gross status is verified like any other. The difference is the outcome: HMRC confirms that the payment can be made with no deduction [1] [14].