Moonworkers
Blog

Car allowance vs company car: the UK payroll maths

Car allowance vs company car compared for UK employers: tax, Class 1 and Class 1A NI, BIK rates, mileage, OpRA rules and worked payroll examples.

Car allowance vs company car: the UK payroll maths

Work out your take-home pay

Income tax, National Insurance and net pay for any UK salary, 2026-27.

This article was written with the help of AI.

HMRC's latest benefits in kind statistics count 920,000 employees receiving a company car benefit, with a total taxable value of £3.07 billion, and fully electric cars now account for 51% of those recipients [1]. For the 2026-27 tax year the appropriate percentage that sets the taxable value of a car runs from 4% for a zero-emission model to 37% for the most polluting [2].

The alternative, a cash car allowance, looks simpler but is taxed in a completely different way. A car allowance is extra pay, so it passes through PAYE with income tax and Class 1 National Insurance for both employee and employer [3] [4]. A company car is a benefit in kind, taxed on a notional value through the tax code or payrolled benefits, with Class 1A National Insurance paid by the employer alone [5].

The gap between the two can be several thousand pounds a year per employee, in either direction, depending on the car's emissions, its list price, the employee's tax band and how much business mileage is driven. The choice also changes what lands on the payslip, what goes on the P11D, and how the employer recovers the cost of the vehicle.

This guide compares the two options line by line for the 2026-27 tax year: the tax and National Insurance on each, worked examples recomputed with the Moonworkers payroll engine, the mileage rules that sit alongside each option, the optional remuneration rules that apply when an employee is offered a choice, and the reporting changes due from April 2027.

Key takeaways

  • A car allowance is earnings: income tax, employee Class 1 National Insurance and employer Class 1 National Insurance at 15% above the secondary threshold all apply [3] [4].
  • A company car is a benefit in kind: the employee pays income tax on list price multiplied by the appropriate percentage, and the employer pays Class 1A at 15% on the same value [5] [2].
  • Electric company cars at 4% usually cost the employee far less tax than an equivalent cash allowance, while high-emission cars at 30% or more often cost more [2].
  • Where an employee can choose cash instead of a car, optional remuneration rules tax the higher of the cash given up and the normal car benefit, except for cars emitting 75g/km or less [6] [7].
  • Business mileage in a private car can be reimbursed tax-free at 55p a mile for the first 10,000 miles, a rate that has no equivalent for company car drivers, who are reimbursed at advisory fuel rates instead [8] [9].

How each option is taxed

The two options sit in different parts of the tax system. A car allowance is general earnings under PAYE, while a company car is a taxable benefit calculated under the benefits code [5] [10].

FeatureCar allowanceCompany car
What is taxedThe cash paidList price × appropriate percentage
Employee income taxThrough PAYE each pay periodThrough the tax code or payrolled benefits
Employee National InsuranceClass 1, 8% main rateNone
Employer National InsuranceClass 1 at 15%Class 1A at 15%
Year-end reportingFPS onlyP11D and P11D(b), or payrolled
Business mileage reimbursementApproved mileage ratesAdvisory fuel rates

Sources: HMRC company car guidance, employer rates and thresholds for 2026-27, and the approved mileage rates [5] [4] [8].

The car allowance as earnings

A car allowance is a cash payment added to salary, usually as a fixed monthly amount, and it is taxed exactly like salary [11] [12]. HMRC's National Insurance Manual is explicit that a payment made to recompense an employee for surrendering entitlement to a company car is not relevant motoring expenditure, so it cannot be disregarded from earnings [3]. The same page treats a round sum allowance that bears no relation to actual motoring costs as additional pay [3].

The relevant motoring expenditure rules do allow certain payments towards private-car costs to be excluded, but only within a qualifying amount calculated from business mileage [13]. A flat allowance paid whether or not the employee drives on business falls outside that relief [3].

The company car as a benefit in kind

An employee pays tax on a company car when it is available for private use, and commuting counts as private use [5]. The taxable value is the list price of the car, plus qualifying accessories, less capital contributions of up to £5,000, multiplied by the appropriate percentage for its CO2 band [10] [2].

The list price is the price before any fleet discount, so the benefit does not fall when the employer negotiates a lower purchase price [10]. Periods of 30 or more consecutive days when the car is unavailable reduce the charge proportionately [10]. The detailed rules are covered in the Moonworkers guide to company car tax.

The 2026-27 appropriate percentages

The appropriate percentage is the single biggest driver of the comparison. For cars emitting between 1 and 50g/km, the electric range also matters [2].

Car typeCO2 emissionsAppropriate percentage
Fully electric0g/km4%
Plug-in hybrid, 130 miles or more1 to 50g/km4%
Plug-in hybrid, 40 to 69 miles1 to 50g/km10%
Plug-in hybrid, under 30 miles1 to 50g/km16%
Petrol120 to 124g/km30%
Petrol or diesel155g/km and above37%

Source: HMRC Employment Income Manual EIM24705 for the 2026-27 tax year [2].

Diesel supplement and maximum

Diesel cars that do not meet the RDE2 standard carry a 4% supplement on top of their band, subject to the 37% ceiling [2] [10]. The government has already set the direction of travel: the zero-emission rate rises to 5% in 2027-28, with most bands moving up by 1 point that year [14]. Rates for 2028-29 and 2029-30 have also been published, rising by 2 points a year for electric cars [15].

Why the percentage outweighs the price

A £45,000 electric car at 4% produces a taxable value of £1,800, while a £35,000 petrol car at 30% produces £10,500 [2] [10]. The cheaper car carries almost six times the taxable value. This is why the comparison with a car allowance cannot be made in the abstract: it depends on the exact vehicle [1].

Worked examples: basic-rate employee

The examples below use an employee in England on a £40,000 salary, tax code 1257L and National Insurance category A, for the 2026-27 tax year. Every figure was computed with the Moonworkers payroll engine, which applies the 2026-27 income tax bands and National Insurance thresholds [11] [12].

A £6,000 car allowance

On £40,000 alone, the employee pays £5,484.20 of income tax and £2,194.40 of National Insurance, taking home £32,321.40 [11] [12]. Adding a £6,000 car allowance raises gross pay to £46,000: income tax becomes £6,684.20 and employee National Insurance £2,674.40, so take-home pay rises to £36,641.40 [11] [12].

The employee keeps £4,320 of the £6,000. On the employer side, Class 1 National Insurance rises from £5,250 to £6,150, an extra £900, so the allowance costs the employer £6,900 in total before any pension contributions that may be due on it [4].

An electric company car instead

A £45,000 electric car at 4% creates a benefit of £1,800. Where HMRC collects the tax through the code, the allowance in the code falls by that amount, from 1257L to 1077L [5] [16]. On that code, income tax rises from £5,484.20 to £5,844.20, a cost of £360 a year, and National Insurance is unchanged at £2,194.40 [11].

The employer pays Class 1A at 15% on £1,800, which is £270, plus the lease or ownership costs of the car itself [4] [17].

A petrol company car instead

A £35,000 petrol car at 30% creates a benefit of £10,500, reducing the code to 207L [2] [16]. Income tax rises to £7,628.40, an increase of £2,144.20, and take-home pay falls to £30,177.20 [11]. The increase is slightly more than 20% of the benefit because the reduced allowance pushes part of the salary into the higher rate band [11].

The employer's Class 1A on £10,500 at 15% is £1,575 [4]. Compared with the electric car, the petrol car costs the employee £1,784.20 more in tax and the employer £1,305 more in Class 1A.

Worked examples: higher-rate employee

The same comparison at a £60,000 salary shows how the employee's marginal rate changes the outcome [11] [12].

The results side by side

The table compares the employee's take-home pay and the change in employer National Insurance for each option, using the engine figures for the 2026-27 tax year [11] [4].

Salary £60,000Income taxEmployee NITake-home pay
Salary only£11,428.40£3,210.60£45,361
Plus £6,000 car allowance£13,828.40£3,330.60£48,841
Electric company car, code 1077L£12,148.40£3,210.60£44,641
Petrol company car, code 207L£15,628.40£3,210.60£41,161

At this salary the employee keeps only £3,480 of the £6,000 allowance, because income tax is charged at 40% and employee National Insurance at 2% above the upper earnings limit [11] [12]. The electric car costs £720 a year in tax, while the petrol car costs £4,200 [2].

Reading the comparison correctly

The take-home figures do not tell the whole story, because the allowance comes with cash and the car comes with a vehicle. An employee taking the allowance must fund a car out of the £3,480 or £4,320 kept, while the company car arrives with lease, insurance and maintenance paid [5] [10]. The fair comparison is the tax cost of the car against the after-tax value of the allowance less the cost of running a private car of similar standard.

The benefit is also not reduced by the employee paying for fuel or insurance; only payments made specifically for private use of the car reduce the taxable value [10].

Business mileage on each option

Mileage rules differ sharply between the two options, and for employees who drive a lot on business they can decide the comparison [18] [9].

Mileage ruleCar allowance (own car)Company car
Tax-free reimbursement55p a mile for first 10,000 miles, 25p afterAdvisory fuel rate for the car
National Insurance-free amount55p for every business mileAdvisory fuel rate
Relief if underpaidMileage Allowance Relief claimNone
Electric car rate55p (same approved rate)7p home charging, 15p public charging

Sources: GOV.UK travel, mileage and fuel rates, the National Insurance rules for mileage, and HMRC advisory fuel rates [8] [19] [9].

Approved mileage payments alongside a car allowance

An employee on a car allowance uses a private car for work, so the employer can also pay approved mileage allowance payments for business journeys [18] [8]. At 55p a mile, 8,000 business miles can be reimbursed with £4,400 free of tax and National Insurance [8] [19].

The car allowance itself does not count towards that approved amount. HMRC's manual says a lump sum paid towards a private car's standing costs must cover only the business proportion of those costs and must not be a payment made merely because the employee no longer has a company car [20]. If the employer pays less than the approved rate, the employee can claim Mileage Allowance Relief on the shortfall [21] [22].

From 6 April 2027 the approved rate above 10,000 business miles rises from 25p to 35p for cars and vans, with the first 10,000 miles staying at 55p [23]. High-mileage drivers on a car allowance are the main beneficiaries.

Fuel for company car drivers

Company car drivers are reimbursed for business fuel at HMRC's advisory fuel rates, which are reviewed quarterly and are far below the approved mileage rate because they cover fuel only [9] [8]. For fully electric company cars the advisory electricity rate is 7p a mile for home charging and 15p for public charging [9].

If the employer pays for any private fuel, a separate fuel benefit charge applies, calculated as the car's appropriate percentage multiplied by £29,200 for the 2026-27 tax year [24] [5]. For the 30% petrol car above, that adds £8,760 of taxable benefit regardless of how much private fuel is actually used [24].

When the employee chooses: optional remuneration rules

Many employers offer a choice between a car and cash. That choice triggers the optional remuneration arrangement (OpRA) rules, which change how the car is taxed [25] [26].

The higher-of rule

Where an employee gives up a right to cash in exchange for a car, the taxable value is the higher of the amount foregone and the normal car benefit [6] [27]. HMRC's own example shows a £5,000 cash allowance given up for a car with a normal benefit of £3,000; the taxable amount is £5,000, reduced only for a capital contribution [6].

The rule applies at recruitment as well as during employment. HMRC's manual describes a job offer with a choice of a £5,000 cash allowance or a company car, and treats the car as provided under optional remuneration arrangements once the individual opts for it [26].

The 75g/km exception

Cars with CO2 emissions of 75g/km or less are excluded from the higher-of comparison and are always taxed on the normal benefit [7] [27]. An electric car offered as an alternative to a £6,000 allowance is therefore still taxed on its £1,800 benefit, which is the main reason low-emission cars dominate both salary sacrifice and cash-or-car schemes [1]. Since 6 April 2019, the amount foregone has also included any connected costs such as insurance or servicing given up as part of the same arrangement [28].

The interaction with salary sacrifice is set out in the guide to salary sacrifice car schemes.

The employer's side of the ledger

The employer's costs go beyond National Insurance. They include the vehicle itself, the capital allowances available on it, the reporting workload and the effect on other pay-related obligations [18] [29].

Capital allowances on company cars

A business that buys a car claims capital allowances based on its emissions. Cars at 50g/km or less go into the main rate pool, at 14% a year (18% before April 2026), while cars above 50g/km go into the special rate pool at 6% [29]. New and unused zero-emission cars qualify for a 100% first-year allowance [29].

That 100% allowance has been extended to 31 March 2027 for Corporation Tax and 5 April 2027 for Income Tax [30]. A car allowance, by contrast, is a deductible employment cost in the year it is paid, with no capital allowance question at all [29].

Pool cars and other exemptions

A genuine pool car, shared by employees for business and normally kept on the employer's premises, carries no benefit charge and does not need to be reported [31]. The exemption is lost if the car is driven for private use beyond what is incidental, so a pool car is not a substitute for either a car allowance or an allocated company car [31] [32].

Minimum wage and pension effects

Allowances do not count towards National Minimum Wage pay unless they are consolidated into standard pay or relate to the worker's performance [33]. An employer cannot use a car allowance to lift a low base rate up to the minimum wage. Whether the allowance is pensionable depends on the scheme rules and the contract, so payroll must hold that flag against the pay element rather than assume it [40]. Employers running mixed pay structures can model the payroll effect with payroll for SMEs.

Reporting each option through payroll

The two options produce very different reporting workloads, and the gap narrows from April 2027 [34].

Reporting a car allowance

A car allowance is reported like any other earnings, as part of taxable pay on each Full Payment Submission [35] [12]. There is no P11D entry and no Class 1A. The only configuration needed is a pay element flagged as taxable, subject to Class 1 National Insurance and, where the scheme says so, pensionable. An HMRC-recognised payroll API handles it as a standard recurring addition.

Reporting a company car

A company car needs in-year notification to HMRC on form P46(car) when a car is first provided, withdrawn or replaced [36] [5]. After the tax year ends, the employer reports the benefit on the P11D and the Class 1A total on the P11D(b) by 6 July, and pays the Class 1A by 22 July if paying electronically [37]. The P11D form guide explains each box.

Mandatory payrolling from 6 April 2027

From 6 April 2027, company cars, car fuel and vans are in the first phase of mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind, with the benefit taxed through payroll each period and Class 1A reported in real time [34] [23]. The tax code adjustment for the car disappears and the benefit appears as a notional pay item on the payslip. For bureaux handling several fleets, payroll bureau software that models benefits per pay period removes most of the year-end P11D work.

Choosing between the two

The comparison usually lands in one of three places, depending on the car and the mileage [2] [8].

SituationUsually more tax-efficientReason
Electric or low-emission car, modest mileageCompany car4% benefit, no OpRA uplift under 75g/km
High-emission carCar allowanceBenefit at 30% to 37% plus fuel benefit
Very high business mileage in own carCar allowance plus approved mileage55p a mile tax-free on business miles

The table summarises the rules above; the actual outcome turns on list price, tax band and mileage [2] [18].

Running the numbers per employee

Because the result depends on each employee's tax code, region and pay, the reliable way to compare is to run both scenarios through a payroll calculation rather than apply a rule of thumb [11] [38]. A Scottish taxpayer, for example, faces different marginal rates on the same allowance. HMRC's company car calculator gives the benefit value, and the employer's payroll gives the effect on take-home pay and employer costs [39] [4].

Model the take-home pay on each option

The Moonworkers UK salary calculator applies the 2026-27 PAYE and National Insurance rules to any gross salary and tax code, so an employer can compare salary plus allowance against a reduced tax code for a company car in seconds.

£ per month

£

e.g. 1257L, S1257L, BR, D0

S = Scotland · C = Wales · W1/M1 = non-cumulative

Enter a salary or hourly rate above

About this calculator

This calculator gives you a close estimate of your UK payroll deductions for 2026-27, using HMRC's exact percentage method with periodised thresholds. It handles the three tax territories, K codes with the 50% regulatory limit and its carry-forward, weeks 53, 54 and 56, the cumulative and W1/M1/X bases, student and postgraduate loans, and pension contributions on qualifying earnings. It still won't match your payslip to the penny in every case: it does not cover in-year tax code changes, payrolled benefits in kind, NI deferral across more than one employment, directors on the annual earnings period, or employer-level annual adjustments such as the Employment Allowance and the apprenticeship levy. Powered by the same engine as the Moonworkers Payroll API.

Run real payroll

Frequently asked questions

Why might the result differ from my payslip?

This calculator uses your current gross pay and tax code to produce an estimate. K-code carry-forwards and weeks 53, 54 and 56 are handled, and the Year-to-date section reproduces a specific period exactly. What your employer may apply that this does not: a mid-year tax code change, benefits in kind processed through payroll, or NI deferral across more than one employment. For most employees on a standard tax code the difference is negligible.

What tax code should I enter?

Use the tax code shown on your most recent payslip or the PAYE Coding Notice (P2) from HMRC. If you're not sure, 1257L is the standard code for most employees resident in England, Wales, or Northern Ireland. Use S1257L for Scotland or C1257L for Wales if you pay Scottish or Welsh income tax.

Which NI category applies to me?

Most employees use Category A. Use M if you are under 21, H if you are an apprentice under 25, or C if you are over State Pension age. Your employer is responsible for assigning the correct category. If in doubt, check your payslip.

Which student loan plan am I on?

Your plan depends on when and where you studied. Plan 1 covers students who started before September 2012. Plan 2 is for English and Welsh students who started from September 2012 to July 2023. Plan 5 applies to English students who started from August 2023. Plan 4 covers Scottish students. You can check your plan at gov.uk or on your payslip.

What is the YTD cumulative PAYE mode?

HMRC's standard method calculates income tax on your total earnings to date each period, then subtracts tax already paid. If you're mid-year and want to see exactly what tax should be deducted in a specific period, expand the Year-to-date section and enter your running totals from previous periods only.

Conclusion

A car allowance and a company car are not two prices for the same thing. One is pay, carrying Class 1 National Insurance on both sides and the full approved mileage regime; the other is a benefit whose cost is set almost entirely by the car's emissions band. At 4%, an electric company car costs a basic-rate employee £360 a year in tax, while a petrol car at 30% costs £2,144.20, and a £6,000 allowance leaves between £3,480 and £4,320 in the employee's pocket depending on the tax band [2] [11].

The balance will keep moving. Electric car percentages rise each year to the end of the decade, the higher mileage rate increases from April 2027, and payrolling turns the company car into a pay-period calculation rather than a year-end form. Employers that hold vehicle data and pay elements in the same payroll record will be able to rerun the comparison whenever a rate changes, rather than revisiting a policy written years earlier.

Frequently asked questions

Is a car allowance taxed the same as salary?

Yes. A car allowance is treated as earnings, so it is subject to income tax through PAYE and to Class 1 National Insurance for both employee and employer. HMRC's National Insurance Manual states that a payment made to compensate an employee for giving up a company car is not relevant motoring expenditure and cannot be disregarded. It is reported on the Full Payment Submission like any other pay [3] [35].

Does an electric company car cost less tax than a car allowance?

Usually, yes. For the 2026-27 tax year a fully electric car is taxed at 4% of its list price, so a £45,000 car creates a benefit of £1,800, costing a basic-rate taxpayer £360 a year. A cash allowance of several thousand pounds is taxed in full, and cars at 75g/km or less are excluded from the optional remuneration higher-of rule [2] [7].

Can an employee on a car allowance also claim mileage?

Yes. An employee using a private car for business can receive approved mileage allowance payments of up to 55p a mile for the first 10,000 business miles and 25p after that, free of tax. If the employer pays less, the employee can claim Mileage Allowance Relief on the difference. The car allowance itself does not count as a mileage payment [8] [20].

Does the employer pay National Insurance on a company car?

Yes. The employer pays Class 1A National Insurance at 15% on the taxable value of the car and on any car fuel benefit. The employee pays no National Insurance on the car. From 6 April 2027 the benefit and the Class 1A are reported through payroll rather than on the P11D [4] [34].